Islamic Point Of View On Democracy Vs Khilafah

    Here i am sharing a very interesting Discussion on the topic "Islamic Point Of View On Democracy and Khilafah" that is done between Muslims with different point of views on this issue.



    Farhan
    I Beleive Democracy is destorying the humanity and the only Soltuion for humanity is Islamic Khilafah.
    Here is a article which i would like to share on this issue. http://www.kalamullah.com/manhaj02.html

    SYED
    Even voting is Haram, it is considered as shirk coz when we are electing a representative for the parliament, we are electing a Taghut(False Idol) Besides Allah Swt.

    Amad
    Democracy is nothing but a hypocrite system where two wolves and a sheep decide what to have for Dinner.
    Two wolves being - the Government and Opposition; and the ignorant innocent Sheep being the common Civilians. and Syed I strongly disagree with your logic about 'Taghut'.

    SYED
    It is not from my mind, it is said by Allah Swt.

    Have you not seen those who pretend that they believe in that which is revealed unto thee and that which was revealed before thee, how they would go for judgment (in their disputes) to taghut when they have been ordered to abjure them? Satan would mislead them far astray.

    An-Nisa verse 60

    Hope it is No more Logical.


    Amad
    jazakAllah

    I initially disagreed, but after going through tasfir of the above verse, I am convinced. But what does other choice do the Muslims belonging to a Non-Muslim governance have?

    The verse talks about the Judgment which does not follows Shariah as going to a Taghut.

    From tafsir Ibn Kathir

    It was reported that the reason behind revealing this Ayah was that; a man from the Ansar and a Jew had a dispute, and the Jew said, "Let us refer to Muhammad to judge between us.'' However, the Muslim man said, "Let us refer to Ka`b bin Al-Ashraf (a Jew) to judge between us.'' It was also reported that; the Ayah was revealed about some hypocrites who pretended to be Muslims, yet they sought to refer to the judgment of Jahiliyyah. Other reasons were also reported behind the revelation of the Ayah

    What should the Muslims under Non-Muslim Governance should do? Moreover, it is stressed on Hypocrites in the facade of being Muslim and not the Non-Muslims.


    Farhan
    they should migrate to a place, which is MUSLIM Majority country.
    .
    like Arab countries, Saudi arabia, yemen, egypt, qatar, oman, Pakistan etc.
    .
    no country has khilafah,,but where we have majority of muslims, the situation there is not Worst, as it is in non-muslim majority countries..
    .
    if a country has majority of muslims, then we see that atleast there the environment is little bit islamic (as compared to non-muslim country, where everywhere you see that muslims are minority and have no rights).


    Hadif
    Brother farhan, i am living in Hindustan where majority is Hindus.. Here i go masjid 5 times a day.. Go to jumua on fridays.. Arrange public programmes and conferences..
    Next let us take the place u lives, muslims themselves destroys masjids, frequent bomb blasts.. Sunni shia riots.. Talibani attack fear.. But here were we live it is safe and we have more freedom to practise islam, even the civil laws in islam.


    Farhan
    Dear hadif
    if i provide you SCHOLARLY Opinion, where scholars have consensus that muslims should NOT Live in non-muslim country.
    would u reject it?
    .
    Also if prophet Muhammad himself said that? what would u do?
    .

    It should be noted that it is not permissible for the Muslim to immigrate to the lands of disbelief except for a necessity or a dire need because immigration to the lands of disbelief cannot be free from violations of Sharee‘ah rules in general. For further information, see Fatwa 86405.

    However, if there is a valid reason for the Muslim to immigrate and stay there, he must abide by the rules and laws which regulate people's life and which do not contradict the rulings of Sharee‘ah. Nonetheless, a Muslim should not abide by the laws that contradict the Sharee‘ah rulings. For instance, if the law forbids the Muslim from inviting people to Islam, he should not abide by that. Rather, he should give Da‘wah within his own capacity. At the same time, he should not violate these laws in a manner that may inflict harm on him; rather, he should invite people to Islam through the available means, which do not put him in a critical situation, such as giving Da‘wah individually. More importantly, the Muslim should be a good example in dealing with others, since this reflects the merits of Islam and its good impact on its followers. Indeed, being a good example effectively encourages people to embrace Islam.

    Finally, we remind the questioner that it is not appropriate to equate Islam, the true religion, with other false religions. Muslims have the right to ban non-Muslims from propagating their religions because this is an invitation to falsehood. Non-Muslims, however, do not have the right to prevent Muslims from calling people to Islam because Islam is the true religion. As regards the fact that non-Muslims believe they are adhering to the truth, it is of no significance.


    Farhan
    muslims are NOT allowed to live in non-muslim land
    http://www.islamweb.net/emainpage/index.php?page=showfatwa&Option=FatwaId&Id=126274
    .
    .
    the Prophet, (peace and blessings be upon him), said, “I disown every Muslim who settles among non-Muslims.” (Reported by Abu Dawud)
    .

    With regard to common sense, the Muslim who settles among non-Muslims cannot carry out many of the duties and everyday acts of worship of Islam, in addition to the fact that he is exposing himself to temptation because permissiveness in those countries is protected by their laws. The Muslim should not expose himself to temptation and trials.

    This is obvious if we look at evidence from the Qur’an and Sunnah without paying attention to what is really happening in Muslim and non-Muslim countries. However, if we look at what is really happening in Muslim countries, we cannot agree with the questioner when he says, “Especially since Muslim countries are no longer so different from others with regard to adherence to the laws of Islam.” This generalization is not altogether correct. Muslim countries vary with regard to how closely or otherwise they adhere to the laws of Islam, and even within one country, regions and cities may vary in that regard.

    Similarly, non-Muslim countries are not all the same with regard to their permissiveness and moral laxity.


    Anayat
    Dear hadif
    first of all the topic is related with democracy and khilafah so why we diverting topic to indo pak issue and issue of nationalism...and brother Hadif in one of your post u have said we are "hindustani muslim" there is no concept of like this hindustani and pakistani muslim in Islam... only we are muslim nothing else if we say we are hindustani muslim that mean we accept nationalism that is clearly haram in Islam but i know the some indian muslim scholers wil accept it as haram because there is some scholer in India they also praying for This so called self pro claimed God Baba..and still people are following these type of mslim scholer blindly.

    On the issue of muslim can live in non muslim country is zanni-ulema has ikhtilaf in this issue both openion is legitimate....

    On the issue of muslim condition in india u said we can pray 5 times freely yes thats true but u said we can organise programme and seminar freely thats not true, we can only organise prog which is totaly based on spritual like Tablighi Jamah and Dr Zakir Naik sb doing but if we organise any type of political programme we will be scaned labeld as extrimist and so on.

    Ahsan
    The Solution to all the problems is Islamic Khilafah where everyone will be treated equally, everyone will get justice and there will be peace everywhere.

Post Title

Islamic Point Of View On Democracy Vs Khilafah


Post URL

http://aticomorcilla.blogspot.com/2011/04/islamic-point-of-view-on-democracy-vs.html


Visit Aticomorcilla for Daily Updated Wedding Dresses Collection

Islamic Point Of View On Following Someone's Order Given In Dream

    Here is a Islamic Discussion that whether we should follow someone's order if we see it in dream?



    Ahmed
    Ibne Athakir said: Abul Fadhal Muhammad bin Fadhal bin al-Muzaffar al-Abdi who is judge in Bahrain told me in the letter. He saw Yazeed bin Muawiyah in the dream. I asked him: Did you kill hussain? Yazeed said No. I asked Allah saved you? He said “Yes” Allah sent me in the paradise.
    [Al Bidaya wal Nihaya vol 16 page no: 299 under the Tarjuma of Yazeed bin Muawiyah]
    .
    Comment: I have seen people quoting their dreams and the dreams of Sufis and they act upon them. Above dream is also the dream of a pious person. What will they do regarding this?
    .
    This topic is not about debate on Yazeed bin Muawiyah, I just wanted to ask question from those who believe that dreams of the pious is an evidence. I will quote other dreams to which they do not agree. Like pious people watching in the dream that Prophet peace be upon him doing Rafa yadain etc.


    Abdul Raheem
    Good point Asim bhai..And aJzakallah for sharing it
    And waiting for more.


    Ahmed
    Imam Abu Jafar Ahmad bin Ishaq said "I was on the madhab of people of Iraq. I saw Prophet peace be upon him in dream, he was praying and doing Rafayadain in first takbeer, in rukoo and after rukoo.[Sunan Darqutni hadeeth no: 1112]
    .
    Comment What about this dream?


    Noor Ul Huda
    but in a hadith of sahe bukhari, muhammad s.a.w.w said that if one sees him (s.a.w.w) in dream it means, he has seen the truth. because satan can not take form of muhammad s.a.w.w.

    if we relate the saying of jafar sadiq r.h. we can negate his dream. he might got confused in his dream or he might have forgotten half part of his dream. we dnt know!!!

    (i don't mean to be harsh or in any way insulting)


    Munaf
    Ahmed you made a very good point......I think the dreams of pious people who are died many years back must be scrutinize just the way we differentiate between strong, weak and fabricated hadith.
    .
    A dream can have any meaning of which only an honest expert can judge what a particular dream means.


    Ahmed
    Ibne Kathir mentioned another dream regarding Yazeed

    His mother saw in dream that she delivered the moon. She narrated her dream to her mother, Her mother said: If your dream is true then surely you will deliver the one who will be the khalipah [Al Bidaya wal Nihaya Vol 16 page 288 biography of Yazeed bin Muawiyah]

Post Title

Islamic Point Of View On Following Someone's Order Given In Dream


Post URL

http://aticomorcilla.blogspot.com/2011/04/islamic-point-of-view-on-following.html


Visit Aticomorcilla for Daily Updated Wedding Dresses Collection

Quran Kareem In Mosque - Islamic Wallpaper

    Quran Kareem In Mosque - Islamic Wallpaper


Post Title

Quran Kareem In Mosque - Islamic Wallpaper


Post URL

http://aticomorcilla.blogspot.com/2011/04/quran-kareem-in-mosque-islamic.html


Visit Aticomorcilla for Daily Updated Wedding Dresses Collection

Read The Quran Its From Allah - Islamic Wallpapers

    Read The Quran Its From Allah - Islamic Wallpapers


Post Title

Read The Quran Its From Allah - Islamic Wallpapers


Post URL

http://aticomorcilla.blogspot.com/2011/04/read-quran-its-from-allah-islamic.html


Visit Aticomorcilla for Daily Updated Wedding Dresses Collection

Holy Quran in Gold Color - Islamic Wallpaper

    Holy Quran in Gold Color - Islamic Wallpaper


Post Title

Holy Quran in Gold Color - Islamic Wallpaper


Post URL

http://aticomorcilla.blogspot.com/2011/04/holy-quran-in-gold-color-islamic.html


Visit Aticomorcilla for Daily Updated Wedding Dresses Collection

Cute Baby In Traditional Saudi Clothes Wallpaper

    Cute Baby In Traditional Saudi Clothes Wallpaper


Post Title

Cute Baby In Traditional Saudi Clothes Wallpaper


Post URL

http://aticomorcilla.blogspot.com/2011/04/cute-baby-in-traditional-saudi-clothes.html


Visit Aticomorcilla for Daily Updated Wedding Dresses Collection

Cute Smiling British Baby Boy Wallpaper

    Cute Smiling British Baby Boy Wallpaper


Post Title

Cute Smiling British Baby Boy Wallpaper


Post URL

http://aticomorcilla.blogspot.com/2011/04/cute-smiling-british-baby-boy-wallpaper.html


Visit Aticomorcilla for Daily Updated Wedding Dresses Collection

Cartoon Baby Wallpaper

    Cartoon Baby Wallpaper


Post Title

Cartoon Baby Wallpaper


Post URL

http://aticomorcilla.blogspot.com/2011/04/cartoon-baby-wallpaper.html


Visit Aticomorcilla for Daily Updated Wedding Dresses Collection

Arab Masjid - Islamic Wallpaper

    Arab Masjid   - Islamic Wallpaper


Post Title

Arab Masjid - Islamic Wallpaper


Post URL

http://aticomorcilla.blogspot.com/2011/04/arab-masjid-islamic-wallpaper.html


Visit Aticomorcilla for Daily Updated Wedding Dresses Collection

Palestine Islamic Wallpapers

    Palestine Islamic Wallpapers



Post Title

Palestine Islamic Wallpapers


Post URL

http://aticomorcilla.blogspot.com/2011/04/palestine-islamic-wallpapers.html


Visit Aticomorcilla for Daily Updated Wedding Dresses Collection

Islamic Clothing For Women Wallpapers

    Islamic Clothing For Women Wallpapers



Post Title

Islamic Clothing For Women Wallpapers


Post URL

http://aticomorcilla.blogspot.com/2011/04/islamic-clothing-for-women-wallpapers.html


Visit Aticomorcilla for Daily Updated Wedding Dresses Collection

Buy Islamic Clothes For Men and Women Online

    Which is the thing whose online shopping is not done today? From Small things like Medicines To big things like Cars are bought today online as the E-Commerce is growing Worldwide.

    E-Commerce has made it very easy to buy things through Internet sitting in your home.  Do you know different type of Islamic Products are also available online that you can buy visiting different Websites. Today I am going to share some popular Websites with you where you can Buy Islamic Cloths for Men and Women like, Abaya, Hijab, Jilbab, Kurta,  Modest Dresses Etc. So following are the Websites from where Islamic Clothes can be bought.

    1 Ali Baba
    Shukronline
    3 Artizara
    4 Eastessence
    5 Desertstore
    Hijabyonline
    7 Alhannah

Post Title

Buy Islamic Clothes For Men and Women Online


Post URL

http://aticomorcilla.blogspot.com/2011/04/buy-islamic-clothes-for-men-and-women.html


Visit Aticomorcilla for Daily Updated Wedding Dresses Collection

South African Cricketer Hashim Amla Example of a True Muslim

    There are many Muslims Celebrities that has made their name in different fields from Showbiz to Sports but you will find very few Muslim Celebrities that are also Practical Muslims.

    South African Cricketer  Hashim Amla is the best example of a Practical Muslim Celebrity who is not only a great Cricketer but also a Complete Muslim.  Hashim Amla follows Islam in his Practical Life as well as when he is on the Ground to play Cricket. Following are Some Examples which shows his greatness.

    Few Years Back South African Cricket Board done a agreement with a Wine Company. Hashim Amla refused to wear the Shirt of South African Team that was having Logo of that Wine Company because Wine is Forbidden In Islam and he not wanted to become part of Promotional Campaign of that Wine Company by Wearing the shirt.. He  paid $500 Dollars Fine every month for not wearing the Shirt with Wine Logo but he never wear that Shirt. Hashim Amla also refused to play in Indian Premier League (IPL) due to Vulgarity in that Tournament .

    He would have easily earned millions of Dollars from IPL but he not done this because he was practical Muslim.  Other Muslim Celebrities also need to learn lesson from Hashim Amla for whom Islam is more important than any other thing.

Post Title

South African Cricketer Hashim Amla Example of a True Muslim


Post URL

http://aticomorcilla.blogspot.com/2011/04/south-african-cricketer-hashim-amla.html


Visit Aticomorcilla for Daily Updated Wedding Dresses Collection

Videos Of Different Parrots Reciting Holy Quran

    Like Human Beings The Animals and Birds are also Creatures of Allah SWT.  Parrot is one of the most popular Bird of the World that is found almost in every Country. Following i have brought Some Interesting Videos of Parrots which are Reciting the Holy Quran. So here are these Videos.






Post Title

Videos Of Different Parrots Reciting Holy Quran


Post URL

http://aticomorcilla.blogspot.com/2011/04/videos-of-different-parrots-reciting.html


Visit Aticomorcilla for Daily Updated Wedding Dresses Collection

Jannah Paradise In Islam

    Today I will be discussing the Concept of Jannah Paradise in Islam and how the life of Jannah Will Be?  According to Islam If you will be having Emaan (Faith) and will go good deeds in this World then you will go to Jannah in hereafter while if you will do bad deeds here then you will enter hell in Hereafter.

     It will be decided on the day of Judgement that who will go to Jannah and who will go to Hell By Allah SWT.  Holy Quran and Hadiths of Or Prophet SAW describes the detail of Jannah in detail.

    According to Hadith there are eight different grades of Jannah in which Jannat-ul-Firdous is the highest while Jannatul Mava is the lowest.  People will enter in different Jannahs according to their deeds. The Jannah is made of Bricks of Gold and Silver. There will be big beautiful gardens and houses in Jannah. There will also be Canals of Milk, Honey, Water and Sharabun Tahoora. There will be no diseases or death in the Jannah and people will always remain happy.  There will be tasty Fruits and other foods in Jannah.


     Every Human will remain young In Jainnah.  People In Jannah Will be Beautiful, Sweet and Long in the Lengths. The People in Jannah will wear Beautiful cloths. There will also be no Urine or stool. There will be Hoors in the Jannah and every Hoor will be far more beautiful than any women of this World.  This Information About Jannah is taken from Hadiths and Quran. For More Detailed Information About Jannah you can rood books on this topic. May Allah SWT send us to Jannat-ul-Firdous in hereafter.

Post Title

Jannah Paradise In Islam


Post URL

http://aticomorcilla.blogspot.com/2011/04/jannah-paradise-in-islam.html


Visit Aticomorcilla for Daily Updated Wedding Dresses Collection

Cute Baby Boy Surfing Facebook Wallpaper

    Cute Baby Boy Surfing Facebook Wallpaper


Post Title

Cute Baby Boy Surfing Facebook Wallpaper


Post URL

http://aticomorcilla.blogspot.com/2011/04/cute-baby-boy-surfing-facebook.html


Visit Aticomorcilla for Daily Updated Wedding Dresses Collection

Cute Baby Girl in Facebook T-Shirt Wallpaper

    Cute Baby Girl in Facebook T-Shirt Wallpaper


Post Title

Cute Baby Girl in Facebook T-Shirt Wallpaper


Post URL

http://aticomorcilla.blogspot.com/2011/04/cute-baby-girl-in-facebook-t-shirt.html


Visit Aticomorcilla for Daily Updated Wedding Dresses Collection

Alhamdulillah With Windows Background - Islamic Wallpaper

    Alhamdulillah With Windows Background - Islamic Wallpaper


Post Title

Alhamdulillah With Windows Background - Islamic Wallpaper


Post URL

http://aticomorcilla.blogspot.com/2011/04/alhamdulillah-with-windows-background.html


Visit Aticomorcilla for Daily Updated Wedding Dresses Collection

Wa Huwa Ala Kulli Shayin Qadir - Islamic Calligraphy Wallpaper

    Wa Huwa Ala Kulli Shayin Qadir - Islamic Calligraphy Wallpaper


Post Title

Wa Huwa Ala Kulli Shayin Qadir - Islamic Calligraphy Wallpaper


Post URL

http://aticomorcilla.blogspot.com/2011/04/wa-huwa-ala-kulli-shayin-qadir-islamic.html


Visit Aticomorcilla for Daily Updated Wedding Dresses Collection

Flowers In Mosque - Islamic Wallpaper

    Flowers In Mosque - Islamic Wallpaper


Post Title

Flowers In Mosque - Islamic Wallpaper


Post URL

http://aticomorcilla.blogspot.com/2011/04/flowers-in-mosque-islamic-wallpaper.html


Visit Aticomorcilla for Daily Updated Wedding Dresses Collection

New Islamic TV Channel Peace TV Bangla Coming In Few Weeks

    There are many Islamic TV Channels working around the world and spreading message of Islam to Mankind but when you will talk about the best Islamic TV Channel of the World the name that will come in your mind is Peace TV.

    Peace TV is the most watched Islamic TV Channels having Millions of viewers around the World. Until now there are two Islamic Tv Channels in Peace Network Peace TV English and Peace TV Urdu.  Peace TV English is for the views which knows English. It is mostly watched in Western Countries and US. Peace TV Urdu is for the viewers which knows Urdu and Hindi. It is mostly watched in Pakistan and India.

    The Good news is that soon in next few weeks a new Islamic TV Channel is going to be launched by Peace Network which will be called Peace TV Bangla and it will be in Bengali language. There are millions of people in South Asia which knows Bengali language so Peace Tv Bangla will prove very useful for them.

     Chairman of Islamic Research Foundation Dr Zakir Naik first of all announced his plans to launch Peace TV Bangla last year which he repeated in his speech at Oxford Union in January 2011. So if you know Bengali than get ready to watch Peace TV Bangla in next few weeks. Following is a Video of Dr Zakir Naik in which he made announcement about launching Peace TV Bangla.



Post Title

New Islamic TV Channel Peace TV Bangla Coming In Few Weeks


Post URL

http://aticomorcilla.blogspot.com/2011/04/new-islamic-tv-channel-peace-tv-bangla.html


Visit Aticomorcilla for Daily Updated Wedding Dresses Collection

Does Allah Know The Future?

    Following I am Sharing A Interesting Discussion Between Muslims and Non-Muslims On Topic  "Does Allah Know The Future?" that was done on Orkut.


    Dave
    Does Allah know the future?
    Does Allah know all that will happen in the future?....or Allah also does not know what will happen in the future and hence is not omniscient (all knowing).

    Farhan
    If we say No, you will say Allah is not God.
    if someone said Yes, then you will say why he tests us?
    .
    .
    so please proceed further.

    Dave
    Good...Farhan..u r intelligent boy...u can think and use ur brains...unlike most others who just blindly believe without using brains....

    So u see Farhan there are logical inconsistencies in the concept of God...


    Farhan
    the answer is very simple.
    No doubt Allah is All-knowing.
    and he Does tests us.
    .
    but Allah does NOT tests us bcoz he does NOT knows the future.
    .
    Allah tests us for US,,not to KNOW that what we will do in certain test.
    .
    .
    take an example.
    .
    Why does a teacher tests us? the test is for STUDENTS, so that they can make themselves strong, and KNOW that how much they know about certain subject. but certain teachers surely have 100% idea that which student will get how much marks,,he will pass or fail.
    .

    majority of tests are to Purity ourselves.
    some tests are to make us Strong
    some tests are there to show us that at what level of Imaan we are.
    some tests are to bring us close to Allah,when we are away from Allah.
    .
    i hope that now the question, that WHY Allah tests us, has been answered.


    Noor Ul Huda
    future, present , past are not for ALLAH, the creator of ALL the ALL-KNOWER.
    time, space, dimensions are created by the creator for the creation.



    Aamir Mustafa
    Lets Have a Different analogy ....
    Have you ever done the computer programming ?? Have you ever written a Computer Code with different control statements ?? Like IF, THEN, ELSE and the different control SWITCHES ????

    And the Principle of GIGO (Garbage In - Garbage Out) Well I will come to GIGO later.

    Well to a large extent our lives are also like a Computer Program. A very large array of code where every situation is like IF THEN ELSE kind of Situations, Don't we have situations at every second of our life where we have to make choice between a number of options we have like

    ITS RAINING OUTSIDE

    Shall I go Out ??

    You make a CHOICE YES or NO depending upon the kind of urgency you have!! Isn't it ?? You got wet (if you have nothing to protect you from rain) if you made a choice YES or you may choose to remain Dry if you choose NO. That doesn't mean that you were predestined got wet. It was your freewill which made you to choose between Wet & Dry ... both the things were destined for you but you shaped-up the future with your Freewill.

    Same is the situation with our whole life Allah(S.W.T) had already destined everything for us or talking in terms of Analogy already Programmed our life. But the results of this Programming is on our free will. So, these IF THEN ELSE Statements are the free will heuristics and making a Choice out of Number of option is the TEST, how do you choose between a Number of Options??? Simply you have Certain Criterion ?? For us i.e, Muslim this Criterion is Quran as Allah says in Quran.

    And who destined and [then] guided (Al-A'laa : 3)

    And

    Have We not made for him two eyes?
    And a tongue and two lips?
    And have shown him the two ways? (Al-Balad: 8-10)

    Blessed is He who sent down the Criterion upon His Servant that he may be to the worlds a Warner - (Al-Furqaan: 1)

    So the Quran is not only a Criterion for Muslims but for all humanity but not all humans make this Fair Choice in choosing their criterion, rather they choose the saying and words of those who have no knowledge or authority, they choose their whims and desires to quantify what is RIGHT and What is WRONG. The two ways are told to mankind time to time in revealed scriptures...

    Now Come to GIGO (Garbage In - Garbage Out), well this simple principle of Computer programming explains many thing and if I would explain it with a single verse of Quran it will explain everything right from What is this Predestination (like both getting wet and Dry predestined) and why some people would go to Hell and some will find their Abode in Paradise. Allah Says In Quran.

    What comes to you of good is from Allah , but what comes to you of evil, [O man], is from yourself. And We have sent you, [O Muhammad], to the people as a messenger, and sufficient is Allah as Witness. (An-Nisa :79)

    Well what is this verse ?? Its nothing but GIGO!! Allah has destined everything which is good for you, but we human make some absurd (garbage) Choices which end up in Garbage results. Allah(S.W.T) is not to be blamed. Its only the free will, belief & acting on wrong Criterion which mess up things for us. Allah(S.W.T) has given us a Criterion if we would act on it we will not get what is Garbage but good which is Predestined by Allah for us.

    Now come to third and final part of the Paradox namely Allah(S.W.T) knows everything that means he knows what Options we would choose or the How we will act based on our free will. Well answer to this Question is a rather complex and for believers the verse above (An-Nisa :79 ) will only suffice. But for those who are confused, let them then consider God to be an entity unlike Human beings, just like the verse of Surah Ikhlas say

    Nor is there to Him any equivalent. (Al-Ikhlass:4)

    So the Knowledge of Allah must not be like the Knowledge of we Humans, we humans mess up our thinking about Allah when we try to Imagine Allah with our human frame of Reference while it is clear that there is no Likeliness of Allah anywhere. he is one and Unique, never born and never to die. SO how does his knowledge is unlike the knowledge of we Humans. Let me Quote me another verse of Holy Quran to make you understand this,

    Allah says

    And they urge you to hasten the punishment. But Allah will never fail in His promise. And indeed, a day with your Lord is like a thousand years of those which you count. (Al-Hajj: 47)

    See the frame of Reference of Allah, what you say a Day i.e, 24 hours it is even lesser than a second for Allah, as Allah says a Day for Allah is Equivalent to a Thousand Years... take note of the plural years. It could be a thousand to any thousand years ... we do not know, But that is how the knowledge of Allah encompasses and a several thousand fold superior to what we have, he know every of our step that we take in a blink of eye, because for him (his frame of reference) that blink is even lesser than a part of thousands of that blink. So, the frame of reference of Allah is not like the frame of reference of we humans.

    Scientifically this Concept is known as the Concept of Time Dilation derived from the theory of Relativity.

    Meaning, According to Quran a Day in the frame of Reference of Allah is somewhat like thousand years , so that means what is for us is a Day for Allah it is = 1/thousand years, then Imagine what would be the length of a Minute or a second, its even lesser than you can imagine, That is why we say that we do not even raise our step and Allah knows it, because in Allah(S.W.T) ' s frame of reference it had already occurred while we have not even raised our step. That is why he also have the knowledge of our free Choices, which means Allah have forced nothing on us in terms of our destiny (or predestination) even though he is aware of what we do in Advance. And Allah is not responsible for all the bad choices we make.

    As Allah says in Quran.

    Allah does not charge a soul except [with that within] its capacity. It will have [the consequence of] what [good] it has gained, and it will bear [the consequence of] what [evil] it has earned. ........ (Al-Baqara: 286)


    Its just like a Programmer knows everything about his Program (this is predestination) on what would be the results depending upon what a user choose. while Allah is superior in his Programming because he had programmed everything in our life good or bad and we only make our choices, but because the frame of reference of Allah is not like the frame of reference of we humans, he has the knowledge of what choices we will make beforehand.

Post Title

Does Allah Know The Future?


Post URL

http://aticomorcilla.blogspot.com/2011/04/does-allah-know-future.html


Visit Aticomorcilla for Daily Updated Wedding Dresses Collection

Is Doing Dua With Waseelah of Prophet Muhammad SAW Allowed?

    Here is a Discussion on Topic of Is Doing Dua With Waseelah of Prophet Muhammad SAW Allowed In Islam or not?


    Sheikh
    if anyone asks me that what is your aqeeda about asking with the wasilah of mohammad salalaho alaihe wasalam ?
    and i reply neither i say its halal nor i say its haram . i just say ask help directly from ALLAH ta'ala .
    is it a correct aqeedah ?
    or i should have to believe in one of the two things that either its haram or halal ?


    Abdullah
    Its not halal at least , as for as my understanding is concerned.
    The only wasila (intercession) of prophet (SA) we know about is on the day of judgement. Not in this life.
    off course Allah knows the best.

    Nadeem
    Tawassul: Islamic vs. bid’ah
    http://www.islamqa.com/en/ref/3297


    Nadeem
    Plus there are many types of tawassul.
    Some are shirk, some are bidah and some are recommended i.e allowed.

    The tawassul you mentioned (asking Allah by saying O Allah i ask you only by the right of your Prophet peace be upon him) is not shirk but a Bidah. Some scholars say it is permissible, some say better to leave this kind of tawassul because we should not indulge in doubt.

    Shirk is directly asking help by saying YA GAWTH AL ADHAM MADAD, or YA Ahmad Raza Khan Madad and something like that.


    Sheikh
    can you share views of some famous classical scholar who say its biddah
    and views of those who say its permissible .


    Nadeem
    well those who say it is not allowed are all the sahaba specially Ameer ul Momineen Omar bin Khattab ra when he said “O Allaah, we used to beseech You by means of (the du’aa’ of) Your Prophet for rain and You would give us rain; now we beseech You by means of (the du’aa’ of) the paternal uncle of Your Prophet, so grant us rain.” [Bukhari]
    .
    and see his creed here regarding asking from dead saint or Prophet
    .
    http://www.systemoflife.com/articles/aqeedah/195-umar-bin-al-khattab-and-grave-worship
    .
    and see plenty of classical scholars here: http://www.systemoflife.com/articles/aqeedah/134-asking-from-dead-is-shirk-from-quransunnah-and-ijma
    .
    those who said its allowed were qadhi Shokani and likes of him but even he said asking from dead is the act of grave worshipers and he said Prophet peace be upon him had no ikhtiyaar to save any one. He just allowed the tawassul you mentioned.

Post Title

Is Doing Dua With Waseelah of Prophet Muhammad SAW Allowed?


Post URL

http://aticomorcilla.blogspot.com/2011/04/is-doing-dua-with-waseelah-of-prophet.html


Visit Aticomorcilla for Daily Updated Wedding Dresses Collection

Popular Posts

My Blog List

Blog Archive